In the current real estate landscape, the decision to buy or rent an HDB flat in Singapore has become more complex, especially in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the pandemic initially caused uncertainty in the resale market, the government’s response and market recovery measures have successfully stabilized and even boosted the HDB resale market. With the implementation of virtual viewings and market stabilization measures, flat prices have recovered and even surpassed pre-pandemic levels. However, depending on the situations, renting may be more financially advantageous than buying for some.
In this blog post, we’ll explore some key considerations to keep in mind when deciding whether to buy or rent an HDB flat in Singapore. By the end of this post, you should have clarity on these considerations and be able to make the right choice for your situation.
Buying a HDB flat can be a wise choice for many reasons. For one, you get to decorate your own home without needing to ask your landlord for permission. Plus, you won’t have to worry about rent hikes or suddenly being evicted. And let’s be real, Singaporeans love owning property – it’s practically a national pastime. Plus, there’s just something satisfying about being able to say, “I own this place.” However, before you take the plunge, do your research and make sure you can afford it. The last thing you want is to be stuck with a flat you can’t pay for.
Renting a HDB flat can be a financially savvy option for those who value flexibility and don’t want to be tied down to a long-term commitment. You don’t have to worry about hefty down payments or being stuck in a particular location. Plus, if you’re the type of person who likes to switch things up frequently, you can always move to a new place without having to worry about selling off your property first. And let’s not forget the added perk of not having to deal with pesky maintenance issues that come with owning a property. Just sit back, relax, and let your landlord handle it. Renting can be a great way to live your best life without all the financial baggage that comes with home ownership.
As such, it is important to carefully consider your financial situation and goals before deciding whether to buy or rent a home in Singapore.
In the next part of this post, I will examine some of the key factors you should consider before making a decision.
Deciding whether to rent or buy a home can be a major life decision, especially when it comes to HDB flats in Singapore. While buying may seem like the more traditional route to take, renting also has its advantages. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or simply weighing your options, there are several key factors to consider before making your decision. In this post, we’ll take a look at the top six considerations you should keep in mind when choosing whether to rent or buy an HDB flat.
If you’re thinking about buying or renting a HDB flat, your financial situation is definitely one of the key factors to consider. Let’s be real – we all know that property in Singapore can be pricey, and the additional costs involved in buying a flat can add up pretty quickly. Stamp duty, cash over valuation… it’s enough to make anyone’s head spin!
On the flip side, using your CPF to buy a flat can be a good option if you’ve got some savings stashed away, and it gives you a bit more financial flexibility in the long run. But if you’re not able to meet the minimum downpayment required by CPF policy, renting might be the more realistic choice.
When it comes to buying or renting a home, your lifestyle preferences are crucial. Some prefer the feeling of control that comes with owning their own property, while others love the flexibility and convenience of renting. For those looking to purchase, a BTO flat or resale HDB flat may be a more viable option.
But let’s be real, owning a property also comes with its own set of responsibilities and expenses, such as monthly maintenance fees, taxes, and mortgage payments. Plus, coming up with the initial downpayment can be a daunting task that requires sacrifices like giving up your bubble tea habit for a while.
On the other hand, renting may provide the opportunity to live in a desirable location or even a luxurious property without the added stress of maintaining it. However, you do have to deal with the occasional nightmare landlord who may turn your life upside down. So choose your rental property wisely, or else you’ll end up stuck with an unreasonable landlord who makes you wish you had stayed at your parents’ place.
Family planning is an important consideration when deciding between buying or renting a home. If you’re planning to start a family, you’ll want to make sure that the HDB flat you’re considering has enough space to accommodate your little ones. Unless you want to play Twister in your living room every day, it may make sense to buy a larger home. However, if you’re planning to remain child-free or have a smaller family, a smaller flat or renting may be more practical.
Another crucial factor to consider is your career path. If you’re eyeing a career change, it may not be the best time to commit to buying a home. Your new job could be in a different part of Singapore, or you may need to relocate for better opportunities. In these cases, renting until you have a clearer idea of where you want to settle down may be more cost-effective. Plus, you won’t have to deal with the added stress of a mortgage on top of a new job.
Another factor to consider is the potential for depreciation of the HDB flat’s value. While HDB flats have historically appreciated in value, there are concerns that older resale HDB flats may not hold their value as well as newer ones, especially as the remaining lease on the flat approaches its end date.
For HDB properties that is going through a lease decay, there is a good possibility that such resale flat prices would drop in the future. This is made worse considering the fact that flat buyer will have to reside in the HDB unit for a minimum of 5 years before they can sell in the open market.
This can result in a situation where the homeowner may struggle to sell the flat for a good price, potentially leading to a loss in value. This will make buying an older resale worth less attractive to a young buyers especially if they are concerned about their future HDB resale flat price.
Aside from the obvious costs of buying or renting a home, there are also several other “unseen” costs to consider. For instance, homeowners should expect to spend money on renovations and repairs as the home ages. Similarly, those who opt for older resale flats should be prepared for defects such as leaking pipes or outdated fixtures. On the other hand, those who choose to rent may not have to worry about these types of issues as much, as fixtures are largely maintained by the landlord. However, renters may be required to pay for minor repairs or cleaning fees upon moving out. It is important to consider these additional costs when deciding between owning or renting a home.
Capital appreciation refers to the increase in value of your property over time, and it’s a crucial factor in determining whether it makes more sense to rent or buy a flat.
Ignoring capital appreciation can lead to a skewed understanding of the overall cost involved in owning or renting a HDB flat. Renting a flat may seem cheaper in the short term, as the monthly rent payments are lower than the monthly mortgage payments for a purchased flat. However, in the long run, buying a flat can be a more financially sound decision if the property’s value increases over time.
When you buy a flat, you’re essentially investing in a property. If the property’s value increases over time, your investment can appreciate, meaning you can potentially sell the property for more than you paid for it. This can provide a significant return on investment and even help you accumulate wealth over the long term.
On the other hand, when you rent a flat, you don’t have the opportunity to benefit from any capital appreciation. You’re essentially paying for the right to occupy the property, but you don’t have any ownership stake in it.
When considering whether to buy or rent a property, there are certain expenses that are exclusive to buying, which can significantly impact your financial situation. Some of these expenses include:
Downpayment: When you buy a property, you will need to make a down payment, which is typically a percentage of the purchase price. In Singapore, the minimum down payment for HDB flats is 10% of the purchase price, while the down payment for private properties is usually higher. The size of the down payment will depend on factors such as the value of the property and your financial situation.
Legal and conveyancing fees: You will need to engage a lawyer to handle the legal and conveyancing aspects of the property purchase. The fees for these services can vary depending on the complexity of the transaction and the lawyer’s rates.
Stamp duty: When you buy a property, you will need to pay stamp duty, which is a tax on the property transfer. The amount of stamp duty you need to pay will depend on factors such as the value of the property, the type of property, and whether you are a Singapore citizen or a foreigner.
Property valuation fees: Before you can obtain a home loan, the lender will require a property valuation to be carried out to determine the market value of the property. The cost of the valuation can vary depending on the property value and the valuer’s rates.
Renovation and furnishing costs: When you buy a property, you may need to incur additional costs for renovation and furnishing, especially if the property is not in move-in condition.
Below are expenses typically associated with renting
Security deposit: When you rent a property, you will usually be required to pay a security deposit, which is typically equivalent to one or two months’ rent. The purpose of the security deposit is to cover any damages or outstanding rent when you move out of the property.
Monthly rent: When you rent a property, you will need to pay a monthly rent, which can vary depending on the location, size, and condition of the property. The rental rate may also increase over time, depending on the terms of the lease.
Rental agent fees: If you use a rental agent to find a property, you may need to pay a fee or commission, which is typically equivalent to one month’s rent.
Moving costs: If you need to move to a new rental property, you may need to incur expenses for hiring a moving company, buying packing materials, and transporting your belongings.
It is important to factor in these expenses when considering whether to rent or buy a property. While renting may seem less expensive in the short term, the costs can add up over time, especially if you are renting for an extended period.
Buying a $500,000 HDB (HDB loan)
Total Expenditure over 2 years: $159,880++
Renting a $500,000 HDB
When comparing between buying and renting a HDB flat, it is essential to consider the paid-up capital involved. While renting may appear cheaper in the short term, purchasing a flat with a significant paid-up capital can provide long-term financial benefits.
Let me explain further.
Paid-up capital is a critical factor to consider when comparing between buying and renting a Housing and Development Board (HDB) flat in Singapore. Paid-up capital refers to the amount of money you invest when you purchase a property. When you buy an HDB flat, you will have to pay a certain amount of money as a down payment, which constitutes your paid-up capital.
Ignoring paid-up capital when comparing between buying and renting a HDB could lead to a skewed understanding of the overall cost involved. Renting a flat may seem cheaper in the short term, as the monthly rent payments are lower than the monthly mortgage payments for a purchased flat. However, in the long run, buying a flat can be a more financially sound decision if you have the ability to make a significant down payment.
When you purchase a flat, you build up equity in your property, which can appreciate in value over time. This means that your paid-up capital can increase in value, providing you with a return on your investment when you sell the flat. On the other hand, when you rent a flat, you do not build up equity, and your monthly rent payments do not provide you with any financial return.
Therefore, when comparing between buying and renting a HDB flat, it is essential to consider the paid-up capital involved. While renting may appear cheaper in the short term, purchasing a flat with a significant paid-up capital can provide long-term financial benefits.
In conclusion, home ownership offers many intangible benefits for families with children that go beyond financial considerations. Having a place to call your own provides a sense of pride, security, and stability that can be especially important for children. As a real estate professional, I believe that owning a home is not just a financial investment, but an investment in the well-being of your family. Whether it’s creating a comfortable living space, establishing roots in a community, or providing a stable environment for your children to grow and thrive, home ownership can be an essential part of building a happy and fulfilling family life.
As a realtor working in a continuously changing economic landscape, it is increasingly important to advise my clients beyond transactions. Every client’s financial situation is unique, there is no one size fits all solution for every case. As a realtor myself, my job goes beyond transactions, it is important to go beyond my duties and assist my clients to seek the best outcome possible beyond property-related matters.
Need a review on your property investment plans, best buys available or assistance in the marketing of your properties?
Get a 1-time free 30 min consultation
Setting the right price for your property is crucial when it comes to achieving a successful sale in Singapore. Homeowners often make common mistakes, such
The Singapore budget 2023 is eagerly awaited, particularly for its anticipated measures to support housing affordability and accessibility. As the housing market remains a top
Should you take a home loan with a longer or shorter home tenure? In a high inflationary environment like Singapore, I would argue it is
Many who are contemplating selling their HDB flat after 5 years are not aware of the financial considerations that need to be addressed. Here in
The decision to sell your HDB flat is never taken lightly. What are some of the financial consideration sellers should know after their home reach
Aside from the obvious costs of buying or renting a home, there are also several other “unseen” costs to consider. For instance, homeowners should expect to spend money on renovations and repairs as the home ages. Similarly, those who opt for older resale flats should be prepared for defects such as leaking pipes or outdated fixtures. On the other hand, those who choose to rent may not have to worry about these types of issues as much, as fixtures are largely maintained by the landlord. However, renters may be required to pay for minor repairs or cleaning fees upon moving out. It is important to consider these additional costs when deciding between owning or renting a home.
Free feel to contact me by clicking on the WhatsApp icon below or complete the form and I’ll be in touch with you as soon as we can.
We will not, in any circumstances, share your personal information with other individuals or organizations without your permission
Join our mailing list to receive latest new launch promotions and insights on the real estate market.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
As a real estate professional, I understand that many home owners have different financial situations and it is my goal to help each and everyone create their own asset progression path so that they can give their loved ones a financially secure future by making the right property decision.
Copyright © 2019 Tan Hong Jie
No part of this site may be reproduced or reused for any other purposes whatsoever without our prior written permission.
Tan Hong Jie, Huttons Asia Pte Ltd
CEA Licence No: L3008899K/R059918F
Something isn’t clear?
Feel free to contact me, and I will be more than happy to assist with your real estate needs.
